Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Corner Piazza
Discovering the Charm of Corner Piazza
Situated on 1 Eldred-Yulan Rd in the heart of Eldred, NY, Corner Piazza has become a beloved gem for pizza enthusiasts. Known for its old world wood-fired pizza, the restaurant combines traditional cooking techniques with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The moment you step inside, you're greeted by a warm atmosphere that feels like a second home, thanks to the friendly demeanor of owner Lou and his dedicated team of staff.
Walking through the doors, the rich aroma of freshly baked pizza envelops you, instantly whetting your appetite. The meatballs, highly recommended by returning customers, serve as a tantalizing appetizer; they are served with a delightful dollop of ricotta that elevates the overall experience. For those who prefer simplicity, the plain and margherita pizzas have garnered rave reviews as some of the best around. One bite and you'll understand why locals are raving—each pizza showcases a perfect balance of flavors and textures that make it truly unforgettable.
What sets Corner Piazza apart is its commitment to quality. They grow their own herbs, tomatoes, and peppers, ensuring that every dish is brimming with freshness. This attention to detail resonates with patrons who travel from distances just to savor the unique offerings. The outdoor patio is an inviting spot to enjoy a meal, especially during the warmer months, where visitors can enjoy a leisurely dining experience surrounded by nature.
Many guests, like Bill Megela and Ray K, note the welcoming spirit of the staff, enhancing the overall dining experience. With a selection of decent beers to match the food, your taste buds will definitely dance with delight as you enjoy your meal. Plus, the location makes it easy to explore the nearby Corner Store for some refreshing ice cream after your meal—perfect for wrapping up a delightful outing.
In an era where fast food often overshadows quality dining, Corner Piazza stands steadfast as a reminder of what great food should taste like—a perfect blend of passion, tradition, and community spirit. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this establishment is a must-visit, where every meal tells a story. Dive into the culinary delights that await you at Corner Piazza, and prepare to be pleasantly surprised!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Old world wood fired pizza. I have never had any better. Lou is such a great guy and I always feel at home there. This pizza is so good it is unbelievable. If you go there try the meatballs as an appetizer you won't be disappointed. ”
“ Wish was open everyday!! The Pizza is delicious!! Plain and margarita is my favorite!! My new favorite place! Living upstate it's hard to find good pizza and super close to me in Glen spey. Also heats back up GREAT for leftovers! Wish I went sooner ”
“ My wife and I drove by on a Friday night and saw it bustling. Decided to swing by Sunday for lunch on our way back home and are very glad we did. Food was excellent, decent beer choice, and the staff was a pleasure. We'll definitely be regularly stopping here on our trips north. ”
“ Great wood fired pizza! Nice outdoor patio with plenty of seating. Great place to stop for some good eats. Staff was very friendly and helpful. If you get a chance take a walk across the street to the Corner Store for some ice cream. Will definitely be back! ”
“ We travel from Morris County NJ for this pizza! They grow their own herbs tomatoes & peppers. Pizza is delicious & staff is awesome! Then you can go across the road for delicious ice cream! Oh, their meatballs are to die for & they serve them w a dollop of ricotta ”
“ I can’t say enough about this place. The quality of the pizza, the attention to detail.l, and best of all Lou and Frank. They’re two incredible people and we were so grateful to have met them over their delicious pizza. We highly recommend this place. 5 ”
“ Like its name says, the Corner Pizza is at the corner of NY55 & NY32 about 4 miles north of Barryville on Rt97. Out of the way? Maybe. Worth the trip? Definitely! Run by a pair of twin brothers, this open air pizzeria, offers a selection of delicious pizzas topped with locally grown tomatoes, peppers and other toppings and cooked in their wood fired oven. They have an extensive offering of bottled beer as well as soft drinks, tea and the like. Seating is limited to less than 10 tables and another half dozen bar height seats at the kitchen bar and when the place is busy the wait for food can be long. ”
“ Great pizza, great staff/ owners. Never disappoints. Even topped it off today with a dessert pizza, apple crumb. We make it at least an every other week visit. Tasty, cooked perfectly and the outside just adds to the experience ”